Point

Verdens 2 førende whiskyskribenter har begge givet point på en skala fra 0-100. Desværre ikke den samme skala. Nedenstående tabel er en sammenligning af deres skalaer.

Jim MurrayPointMichael Jackson
Nothing short of absolutely diabolical0-49,5(ikke kommenteret)
50-50,5Savner balance og/eller karakter. Var måske ikke tiltænkt aftapning som single malt.
Nasty and well worth avoiding51-59,5
60-64,5Behagelig, men ikke exceptionel malt
Very unimpressive indeed65-69,5
Usually drinkable but don't expect the earth to move70-74,5Værd at prøve
Average and usually pleasant though sometimes flawed75-79,5Absolut værd at prøve
Good whisky worth trying80-84,5Markant og exceptionelt
Very good to excellent whiskies definately worth buying85-89,5
Brilliant90-93,5De helt store single malts
Superstar whiskies that give us all a reason to live94-97,5
Better than anything I've ever tasted98-100

MurrayJacksonDestilleri navnFlaske navnAlderAlk.Aftapper
67,092,0MacAllanThe MacAllan Twentiesukendt40,0
92,092,0MacAllanThe MacAllan Fiftiesukendt40,0
92,0Tasman DistilleryGreat Outback Rare Old Australian Single Maltukendt 
92,0SLYRS Destillerie GmbH & Co. KGSlyrs Edition Dallmayr 2004ukendt55,0
92,0BruichladdichOctomore 04.1 / 167 ppm562,5
92,0ArdbegSmokehead - Islay Single Maltcirka 743,0Ian Macleod Distillers
92,088,0LaphroaigLaphroaig 10 cask strength1057,3
92,0ArdbegArdbeg Renaissancecirka 1055,9
92,0GlendronachGlenDronach 12 - Original (ny: dobbelt sherry lagret)1243,0
92,0GlenmorangieGlenmorangie - The Quinta Rubancirka 1246,0
92,0MacAllanThe MacAllan 151543,0
92,0Highland ParkHighland Park 151540,0
92,0BruichladdichThe XVII1740,0
95,592,0Highland ParkHighland Park 181843,0
92,084,0GlenmorangieGlenmorangie 19772143,0
92,0Isle of JuraIsle of Jura 21 - Cask Strength2158,1
92,0Port EllenPort Ellen 1979, 1st Release (2001)2256,2
92,0TaliskerTalisker 25 / Bottled 20082554,2
92,078,0GlendronachThe GlenDronach 1968cirka 2543,0
92,0BenromachBenromach 252543,0
92,0PulteneyOld Pulteney 303044,0
92,087,0GlenfarclasGlenfarclas 40 Millenium Edition4054,7
92,0GlenfarclasGlenfarclas 505044,4